Disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you buy through them, AI Tools for Educators may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
Grading is where many teachers lose their evenings. AI can draft rubric scores and comments so you are reviewing and sending feedback, instead of writing every note from scratch. It should not be the final grade: every serious tool on this list still expects you to look at the work first.
This editorial comparison from the AI Tools for Educators team is for K-12 teachers, mainly in the US and the UK, not a classroom trial write-up and not a set of invented teacher stories. Every price, plan limit, feature and privacy claim below comes from the vendor's own website, checked on 22 November 2026. Confirm the figure at checkout.
Some tools here are purpose-built essay graders (CoGrader, EssayGrader). Others help at the edges of the marking workflow — in-document feedback (Brisk, MagicSchool), writing quality (Grammarly, QuillBot), or academic integrity (GPTZero).
Quick picks
- Best dedicated essay grader to try first: CoGrader — free for 150 submissions a month, including handwritten work.
- Best alternative essay grader: EssayGrader — free for 100 essays a month (up to 1,000 words each); Pro is $14.99 a month for 350 essays.
- Best for feedback inside Google Docs: Brisk Teaching — a free Chrome and Edge extension.
- Best all-in-one toolkit that also does batch writing feedback: MagicSchool — Class Writing Feedback is included on the free plan.
- Best for polishing comments, not scoring rubrics: Grammarly — Pro is $12 a month when billed annually ($144 a year).
- Best add-on for AI-use questions during marking: GPTZero — the free plan covers 10,000 words a month.
If your main job is scoring essays against a rubric, start with CoGrader's free plan. If it is leaving better comments in Google Docs, start with Brisk. Use a detector such as GPTZero as supporting evidence, not as a verdict.
Comparison table
Prices and limits checked on each vendor's own pages on 22 November 2026. District plans are usually quoted, not listed.
| Tool | Best for | Free plan | Paid price | Notable features |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CoGrader | Rubric essay grading, including handwriting | Yes. 150 submissions/month | Individual: $15/month billed annually, or $19/month. Schools: quote | Rubrics; Classroom, Canvas, Schoology; teacher review first. Vendor's Oct 2026 study: 98.3% of 1,764 STAAR responses within one point of official raters. FERPA/COPPA aligned; SOC 2 Type 1 |
| EssayGrader | High-volume essay grading and a large rubric library | Yes. 100 essays/month, up to 1,000 words each | Pro: $14.99/month (350 essays). Premium: $34.99/month (800 essays, up to 8,000 words). Schools: quote | 800+ rubrics; AI-writing and plagiarism checks on Pro. FERPA school-official role; no student accounts (COPPA); no model training on student work |
| Brisk Teaching | In-document feedback and batch comments | Yes. $0 for teachers | Premium and Intelligence: custom school pricing | Chrome/Edge extension in Docs, Slides, YouTube, PDFs and LMS platforms. Vendor states FERPA and COPPA compliance and a 95% Common Sense Privacy rating |
| MagicSchool | Batch writing feedback inside a wider toolkit | Yes. $0, with standard generation limits | Plus: $12.99/month, or $8.33/month billed annually ($99.96/year). Enterprise: quote | Class Writing Feedback based on your rubric. Vendor states FERPA, COPPA, SOC 2 and GDPR compliance |
| Grammarly | Grammar and clarity — not rubric scoring | Yes. $0 | Pro: $12/member/month billed annually ($144/year); $30/month; or $60 per three months. Education: quote | Tone and rewrite suggestions; Authorship on education plans. Education page: customer text never sold or used to train models. No public FERPA/COPPA statement on the pages we opened |
| QuillBot | Teacher-side paraphrasing and quick checks | Yes, with limits on several tools | Premium: $19.95/month, or $99.95/year, or $39.95 every three months, per QuillBot's official blog | Writing, grammar, plagiarism and AI-detector tools. No FERPA/COPPA claim on the Trust Center; individual-plan inputs may be used to improve the service unless you opt out or are on a Team plan |
| GPTZero | AI-writing detection alongside marking, not rubric grading | Yes. 10,000 words/month; basic AI scan | Confirm seat prices on gptzero.me/pricing. Educator page values Premium at $288/year. Professional Team: 500,000 words per member per month | Advanced Scan, writing replay, plagiarism check, Classroom and Canvas on higher plans. Designed to support FERPA compliance; no training on submitted text; SOC 2 Type 2 |
CoGrader: the most complete free starting point for essay marking
CoGrader is a dedicated AI grader for essays and other written submissions. You build or share a rubric, upload or import the work, and review suggested scores and comments before anything goes back to students. The company is explicit: teachers still review every score and comment before students see it.
The Starter plan is free every month and includes 150 student submissions, rubric building and sharing, handwritten assignments, and integrations with Google Classroom, Canvas and Schoology. The Individual plan is $15 a month billed annually, or $19 a month, and raises the cap to 350 submissions, with grammar checking, a class dashboard, AI detection and plagiarism detection. Schools get a size-based quote with unlimited submissions and a shared rubric library.
On its pricing page, CoGrader publishes its own October 2026 comparison with official Texas STAAR raters: 98.3% of 1,764 scores were within one point of the official rater. That is the vendor's own study, not a peer-reviewed replication.
CoGrader's IT pages state that it is FERPA and COPPA aligned and SOC 2 Type 1 attested, that customer data stays in the United States, and that it will sign a DPA. Choose it if you mark a regular load of essays, including handwriting. See also /vs/cograder-vs-essaygrader/.
EssayGrader: another full essay-grading workspace
EssayGrader is the other dedicated platform most teachers will compare with CoGrader. The shape is the same: upload work, apply a rubric, review the suggested marks and comments, then share.
The Basic plan is free and covers up to 100 essays a month at 1,000 words each, with LMS integrations, a rubrics library and grammar reports. Pro is listed at $14.99 a month (the page also shows a "Save 25%" label) and includes 350 essays a month, AI-writing and plagiarism detection, and 800+ aligned rubrics. Premium is $34.99 a month for 800 essays a month, each up to 8,000 words. The public comparison table also showed a "3,500" figure next to the mid-tier column, but surrounding labels did not load clearly enough to confirm that as a Pro word limit. School plans are quoted, with DPAs "signed in 30+ U.S. states," and a vendor claim of ">96% grading accuracy."
EssayGrader's Trust Center (updated September 2026) says it acts as a FERPA school official, has no student accounts (COPPA), does not use student work to train models, and hosts data in the United States. A later note on that page says a SOC 2 Type 1 audit is underway, so ask for the current letter if you need it. Choose EssayGrader for a large rubric library; look at CoGrader first if you need handwriting on a free plan.
Brisk Teaching: feedback where the writing already lives
Not every marking job is an essay uploaded to a grading app. Brisk Teaching is a Chrome and Edge extension that works inside Google Docs, Slides, YouTube, PDFs, webpages, Microsoft tools, and LMS platforms including Canvas, Schoology and Google Classroom.
The official plans page lists Free at $0 for teachers. Paid plans on that page are Premium and Intelligence, both custom-priced for schools on a per-student model. Individual upgrade pricing was not listed on the current plans page, so we have not invented one.
Brisk states that it is FERPA and COPPA compliant, with a 95% Common Sense Privacy rating, and that Premium and Intelligence customers can sign custom DPAs. Choose it for faster comments in the documents students already use, not for a gradebook-style rubric score or stacks of handwritten scripts.
MagicSchool: batch writing feedback inside a wider toolkit
If you already use MagicSchool to plan lessons, Class Writing Feedback is the obvious next step. The official pricing page describes it as a way to review, personalize and send AI-generated feedback in batches, based on your rubric.
MagicSchool Free is $0 and includes 80+ teacher tools, the Raina chatbot, and Class Writing Feedback, with standard generation limits that the FAQ says are visible in your dashboard and reset automatically. Plus is $12.99 a month, or $8.33 a month billed annually ($99.96 a year). Enterprise is quote-based. MagicSchool's pricing and trust pages state FERPA, COPPA, SOC 2 and GDPR compliance. Choose it if you want feedback and lesson planning in one place; if essay grading is your whole problem, CoGrader and EssayGrader are more specialised. See also Best AI tools for lesson planning (2026).
Grammarly: stronger writing, not a substitute rubric
Grammarly is not an essay grader. It will not apply your analytic rubric and return a score. What it can do is tighten the comments you write, catch grammar and clarity issues in student writing, and, on education plans, give instructors a view of how a document was produced through Grammarly Authorship.
The consumer plans page lists Free at $0. Grammarly's support article confirms Pro is $12 per member per month when billed annually ($144 a year), $30 month-to-month, or $60 per member per three months. Pro adds tone adjustments, full-sentence rewrites, AI-text detection, a plagiarism catch, and a higher generative-prompt cap (2,000 per member per month, versus 100 on Free). Grammarly for Education is sold to institutions by quote. That education page says customer data and text are never sold or used to train models. The education pages we opened on 22 November 2026 state GDPR and CCPA compliance, but they did not display a public FERPA or COPPA certification statement. See also Grammarly vs QuillBot for teachers.
QuillBot: useful for teacher writing, with a student-data caution
QuillBot is also not a rubric grader. It is a writing suite: paraphraser, grammar checker, plagiarism checker, AI detector and related tools. Teachers often use it to rephrase a comment or simplify a text. Do not paste identifiable student essays unless your school has approved a Team plan.
An official QuillBot blog article, checked on 22 November 2026, listed Premium at $19.95 a month, $99.95 a year ($8.33 a month), and $39.95 every three months (the article labels that plan "semi-annual" while stating a three-month interval, so go by the checkout screen). Prices can vary by region.
QuillBot's Trust Center does not claim FERPA or COPPA compliance, and it states that on individual plans inputs may be used to train and personalise the service, with opt-outs in the extension settings. It does not train on text inputs from Team plan users.
GPTZero: detection and writing evidence, not a mark
GPTZero will not grade an essay against your rubric. It is an AI-writing detector, with extras that matter when you are already marking: a plagiarism check, writing feedback, and Writing Replay in Google Docs. GPTZero says it is an official AI detector partner of the American Federation of Teachers.
The free plan, described in GPTZero's support centre, includes a basic AI scan, 10,000 words a month, up to 10,000 characters per scan, up to three files in a batch, and one free Advanced Scan. Paid plans add grammar and vocabulary checks, sentence-level highlighting, plagiarism and citation tools, writing feedback, longer scans and LMS integration.
Individual dollar prices did not render in a quoteable form on gptzero.me/pricing on 22 November 2026. Two official figures we could record: the educators page values Premium at $288 a year, and the Professional Team plan includes 500,000 words per member per month. Confirm the live seat price on the pricing page before you subscribe.
GPTZero's support centre says the product is designed to support FERPA compliance, that submitted text is not used for model training, and that it holds SOC 2 Type 2 certification. The company warns that a single flagged scan should not be treated as proof. See also the best AI detectors for teachers.
How to choose
Match the tool to the job, then to your school's privacy rules.
- You mark essays against a rubric, including some handwriting. Start with CoGrader's free 150 submissions. If you prefer EssayGrader's rubric library, try that free plan on the same sample. See also how to grade essays faster with AI and a rubric.
- You mostly leave comments in Google Docs or Classroom. Start with Brisk. Add MagicSchool if you already use it for planning.
- You want to catch grammar and clarify comments. Use Grammarly for that layer, not as the grade itself.
- You need an AI-use signal, not a score. Use GPTZero, then follow your school's policy. Do not accuse a student on a single automated result.
- You were about to paste student essays into a personal paraphrasing account. Don't. QuillBot can help you rewrite your own feedback, but its individual-plan data terms are not equivalent to a K-12 grader with a FERPA statement.
You remain the assessor: read the work, edit the comments so they sound like you, and change any score you disagree with.
Frequently asked questions
Should AI assign the final grade? No. Use it to draft a score and comments, then apply your professional judgement. CoGrader states that teachers still review every score and comment before students see them.
How accurate are these tools? It depends on the rubric, the genre and the paper. CoGrader publishes its own October 2026 STAAR comparison (98.3% within one point of official raters on 1,764 responses). EssayGrader states "greater than 96% grading accuracy" on school plans. Both are vendor claims, so calibrate on a sample of your own assignments.
What is the best free AI grading tool for teachers? For rubric grading, CoGrader's 150 free submissions a month, including handwriting, is the most generous dedicated starting point we found. EssayGrader's free plan (100 essays a month, 1,000-word cap) is a solid second trial. Brisk and MagicSchool are free ways to get comments.
Can I use these tools under FERPA or COPPA? CoGrader, EssayGrader, Brisk and MagicSchool publish FERPA and COPPA positions on the pages we checked. GPTZero is designed to support institutional FERPA compliance. Grammarly's education pages emphasise that customer text is not used for training, but we did not find a public FERPA/COPPA badge on the pages we opened. QuillBot does not claim FERPA or COPPA on its Trust Center. Your school makes the final call.
Will an AI detector prove a student cheated? No. GPTZero itself recommends looking at writing process, patterns across assignments, and conversation with the student. A high AI score is a reason to enquire, not a verdict.
The short version
If you need a rubric score and comments on essays, start with CoGrader, and try EssayGrader on the same sample if you want a second opinion. If you need faster comments in Google Docs, start with Brisk, or with MagicSchool if you already plan there. Add Grammarly to polish writing, and GPTZero when academic integrity is part of the question. Keep QuillBot on the teacher side of the workflow, not as a store for student essays.
Prices, plan limits, features and privacy claims in this article were checked on each vendor's own website on 22 November 2026.